TORVANTA
Compare · data as of 2026-10-16

FCF vs MBIN: First Commonwealth Financial, Corp. vs Merchants Bancorp

First Commonwealth Financial, Corp. (FCF) and Merchants Bancorp (MBIN) on Torvanta's measures: FCF grades higher on 1 of the 4 factor families and MBIN on 1.

FCFMBIN
Value gradeC+C+
Growth gradeC+B-
Profitability graden/an/a
Momentum gradeB+B
Market value$2.1B$2.2B
P/E (trailing)12.5x9.8x
Forward P/E (Torvanta model estimate)SubscribersSubscribers
Revenue, last 12 monthsn/an/a
Revenue growth (y/y)n/an/a
Operating marginn/an/a
Return on invested capitaln/an/a
Free-cash-flow yield9.3%-34.2%
Total return, 1 year+35.0%+57.8%
Total return, 3 yearsn/an/a

Full FCF analysis · Full MBIN analysis

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, FCF or MBIN?

First Commonwealth Financial, Corp. (FCF) and Merchants Bancorp (MBIN) on Torvanta's measures: FCF grades higher on 1 of the 4 factor families and MBIN on 1. Which fits an investor depends on their goals; this is research, not a recommendation. Subscribers see where the model ranks each and its expected return.

Which is cheaper, FCF or MBIN?

On trailing earnings FCF trades at 12.5x and MBIN at 9.8x; their value grades are C+ and C+ against their sectors.

See the Stock Analyst's view

Subscribers get a rating, a fair value estimate, a 12-month target and a risk read for every S&P 500 company, Torvanta's earnings estimates, and three model portfolios (Active, Adaptive and Patient) with every trade sized and explained. A free account includes 3 full Stock Analyst reports a month.

See plans Or get the free weekly newsletter

Torvanta is research only - not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Grades describe a company's reported data against its sector; they are not the model's view, change as data changes and can be wrong. Financial figures come from the company's SEC filings; returns include reinvested dividends. Past performance does not predict future results.

All stock ratings · Stock lists · AI stock research · Model portfolio · Research · Disclaimer