TORVANTA
Compare · data as of 2026-10-06

MCY vs SIGI: Mercury General vs Selective Insurance Group

Mercury General (MCY) and Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) on Torvanta's measures: MCY grades higher on 4 of the 4 factor families and SIGI on 0.

MCYSIGI
Value gradeA+B+
Growth gradeB+C
Profitability gradeA-B-
Momentum gradeB-C-
Market value$5.6B$5.1B
P/E (trailing)6.0x10.6x
Revenue, last 12 months$6.3B$5.5B
Revenue growth (y/y)+10%+7%
Operating marginn/an/a
Return on invested capitaln/an/a
Free-cash-flow yield22.4%23.4%
Total return, 1 year+19.8%+3.3%
Total return, 3 years+280.7%-14.0%

Full MCY analysis · Full SIGI analysis

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, MCY or SIGI?

Mercury General (MCY) and Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) on Torvanta's measures: MCY grades higher on 4 of the 4 factor families and SIGI on 0. Which fits an investor depends on their goals; this is research, not a recommendation. Subscribers see where the model ranks each and its expected return.

Which is cheaper, MCY or SIGI?

On trailing earnings MCY trades at 6.0x and SIGI at 10.6x; their value grades are A+ and B+ against their sectors.

See the model's view

Subscribers get the model's rank and expected return for every covered company, the reasoning behind each, and the Torvanta model portfolio's trades each trading day, sized and explained, at three risk levels.

See plans Or get the free weekly newsletter

Torvanta is research only - not investment advice and not a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Grades describe a company's reported data against its sector; they are not the model's view, change as data changes and can be wrong. Financial figures come from the company's SEC filings; returns include reinvested dividends. Past performance does not predict future results.

All stock ratings · Stock lists · AI stock research · Model portfolio · Research · Disclaimer